HEATED

Share this post

BREAKING: A climate upheaval at Exxon

heated.world

BREAKING: A climate upheaval at Exxon

Exxon’s morally inept and fiscally questionable long-term climate strategy is finally catching up with it.

Emily Atkin
May 26, 2021
22
16
Share this post

BREAKING: A climate upheaval at Exxon

heated.world

Something really wild just happened at ExxonMobil, the 11th-biggest climate-polluting U.S. company. Activist shareholders concerned about climate change have secured a win that could change the trajectory of the historically climate-hostile company.

Twitter avatar for @JuddLegum
Judd Legum @JuddLegum
BREAKING In a major victory for climate change activists, "Engine No. 1 has won at least two board seats at Exxon following a historic battle over the oil giant’s board of directors."
cnbc.comEngine No. 1 wins at least 2 Exxon board seats as activist pushes for climate strategy change
5:30 PM ∙ May 26, 2021
129Likes48Retweets

At the annual shareholder meeting, an activist investor that owns only about 0.02% of the oil giant’s stock secured at least two seats on the oil giant’s board or directors. The activist fund, called Engine No. 1, launched a challenge against the company’s leadership last year, on the basis that that Exxon “lacked a coherent plan for surviving a global transition to cleaner energy sources.”

The votes are still being counted, and it’s possible that at least two more of Engine No. 1’s directors could be selected to Exxon’s board. But even if that doesn’t happen, the outcome is a sign that Exxon’s morally inept and fiscally questionable long-term climate strategy is finally catching up with it.

Twitter avatar for @JavierBlas
Javier Blas @JavierBlas
BREAKING: Exxon activist wins at least two board seats in shareholder vote; a huge rebuke against company's current board and management. CEO Darren Woods is re-elected, however. IMPORTANT: 2 additional board seats are still too close to call, so activist may win more seats #OOTT
5:20 PM ∙ May 26, 2021
49Likes25Retweets

Exxon’s long-term strategy, you may remember, is to significantly ramp up oil production over the next decade, climate crisis be damned. The company released an absolutely laughable “climate plan” a few months ago, which allows the company to increase its carbon emissions in line with that strategy.

The oil giant has also faced heat in recent months for refusing to fully explain to investors how climate change poses a risk to the company; how much and to whom is it giving political contributions; and where its political lobbying efforts are focused.

Engine No. 1’s letter to Exxon’s board back in February railed against all these omissions and contradictions. It said Exxon’s “true [emissions] trajectory is nowhere near” in line with the Paris agreement, and that “none of the Company’s new claims change its long-term trajectory, which would grow total emissions for decades to come.”

“Without new members of the Board with the necessary expertise and experience, ExxonMobil will have little choice but to continue seeking to create the appearance of transformative long-term change, rather than working to make it a reality,” the letter continued.

Twitter avatar for @edwardcmason
Edward Mason @edwardcmason
History has been made at the Exxon AGM today. At least 2 of the Engine No. 1 directors have been elected. Voting on the other two was too close to call. Investors are serious about the transition to net zero.
5:19 PM ∙ May 26, 2021
5Likes1Retweet

Now, it appears many of Exxon’s other shareholders agree with Engine No. 1 — including BlackRock, Exxon’s second largest shareholder, which reportedly backed three of Engine No. 1’s four candidates for the board. The world’s largest asset manager has previously pledged to make climate change central to its investments, and has received a good deal of praise for it.

Twitter avatar for @steelewheelz
graham steele @steelewheelz
Seems like large funds' voting can make an impact. reuters.com/business/energ…
Twitter avatar for @DaveCBenoit
Dave Benoit @DaveCBenoit
One of the biggest activist election wins ever today. And the implications of changing Exxon’s strategy are a lot bigger than salting the pasta water or pricing your razor. https://t.co/IXyCv01Y2M
5:44 PM ∙ May 26, 2021

Still, BlackRock did not back all of Engine No. 1’s candidates. And, as the BlackRock-tracking climate accountability Twitter user @BLKsBigProblem noted yesterday, BlackRock still likely voted to retain Exxon CEO Darren Woods—who has been central to pushing the oil giant’s current strategy—as director of the board.

Twitter avatar for @BLKsBigProblem
BlackRock's Big Problem 👁️ @BLKsBigProblem
𝙀𝙓𝙓𝙊𝙉 𝘼𝙂𝙈 𝙉𝙀𝙒𝙎: @blackrock will vote to retain anti-climate leaders Darren Woods & Kenneth Frazier in top positions despite demands from green investors & activists calling for their removal. @exxonmobil needs visionary climate-conscious leadership; not this.
9:31 PM ∙ May 25, 2021
29Likes17Retweets
Twitter avatar for @BLKsBigProblem
BlackRock's Big Problem 👁️ @BLKsBigProblem
In today's @Reuters exclusive, @sveaherbst reported that BlackRock plans to buck Exxon mgmt to support 3 outside candidates to join Exxon's board. But BlackRock can't have it both ways; accountability starts at the top, and Woods & Frazier have got to go.
reuters.comExclusive: BlackRock backs 3 director nominees challenging Exxon board -sourcesBlackRock, Exxon Mobil Corp’s <a href=“https://www.reuters.com/companies/XOM.N” target=“_blank”>(XOM.N)</a> second largest shareholder, is backing several of upstart hedge fund Engine No. 1′s candidates to join the company’s board, in a blow to the energy giant, according to people familiar with the…
9:33 PM ∙ May 25, 2021
6Likes4Retweets

Still, even though Woods remains director of Exxon’s board, the election of Engine No. 1’s candidates means his influence is in jeopardy, reports World of Oil:

Any dilution of Woods’s influence over the board could derail his long-term plans and force strategic and tactical changes he has previously rejected.

Although Engine No. 1 hasn’t targeted Woods for removal, even a partial victory for the activist would be a serious, and perhaps fatal, blow to his leadership, according to Ceres, a coalition of environmentally active investors managing $37 trillion.

“I don’t see how Darren Woods remains as CEO if one of the dissidents, let alone all four, are elected,” said Andrew Logan, director of oil and gas at Ceres. “It would be such a sign of fundamental dissatisfaction with the status quo that something would have to change. And that starts with the CEO.”

In any case, this is still a developing story with moving parts. But if we can take anything from it so far, it’s that climate activist investors perhaps pose a bigger threat to Big Oil giants than some thought. I’ll update you tomorrow as the whole thing unfolds.


Catch of the Day:

Fish sits regally in his position as the unelected chairman of HEATED’s board. Whomst would launch a challenge to this handsome pup?

OK, that’s all for today—thanks for reading HEATED! If you’d like to share this piece as a web page, click the button below.

Share

To support independent climate journalism that holds the powerful accountable—and to receive HEATED’s reporting and analysis in your inbox four days a week—become a subscriber today.

If you’re a paid subscriber and would like to post a comment, click the “Leave a comment” button:

Leave a comment

Stay hydrated, eat plants, break a sweat, and have a great day!

16
Share this post

BREAKING: A climate upheaval at Exxon

heated.world
16 Comments
Meredith
May 26, 2021Liked by Emily Atkin

I know this is just a tentative, small beginning, but I'm so desperate for anything positive in this that I'm thrilled. Good for Engine1 et al.!! And, if BlackRock is climbing aboard even in a fairly chicken-excrement way; it's a signal that the big boys realize that climate denial is a losing strategy even for them.

Expand full comment
Reply
5 replies
Michael Rader
May 26, 2021Liked by Emily Atkin

I represent an activist fund which contributes .000001% of HEATED's substack revenue and I have serious concerns about Chairman Fish's long-term strategic plan of BARK BARK BARK BARK

Expand full comment
Reply
3 replies by Emily Atkin and others
14 more comments…
TopNewCommunity

No posts

Ready for more?

© 2023 Emily Atkin
Privacy ∙ Terms ∙ Collection notice
Start WritingGet the app
Substack is the home for great writing